NEW DELHI: In a big relief to lakhs of homebuyers, SC has ruled that in housing projects that remained incomplete despite banks releasing major portion of loan instalments to rogue or insolvent builders, the commercial courts, NCLT or NCLAT cannot ask flat buyers to repay the financier without first examining the “unholy” bank-builder nexus.The order came from a bench of CJI Surya Kant, and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana on a petition by homebuyers in Krishna housing project, Gurgaon, by Raheja Developers, which has gone into insolvency proceedings.The petitioners said the bank had started recovery proceedings against them in a commercial court in Saket, New Delhi, even though they had not yet got their flats.The CJI-led bench said, “It is the bounden duty of the commercial court to determine the nexus between the builder and bank officials and to see whether the bank disbursed the loan amount to the builder strictly in terms of the tripartite agreement.”It said unless a categorical finding is returned that the homebuyers are in default, no interim direction regarding payment of instalments can be issued. “We direct the civil court not to take any coercive action against the petitioners or similarly placed homebuyers without first determining the above-mentioned issue,” it said.As per the tripartite agreement between buyers-builder-banks, the financier was to disburse the loan amount directly to the builder in proportion to the progress in construction on ground. However, in many cases, because of builder-bank officials nexus, the financial institutions released loan amounts against each flat buyer much more than the money that should have been disbursed to the builder given the stage of construction of the housing project.When the project remained incomplete for decades, the bank filed recovery suits against homebuyers who, without getting the flats, kept paying EMIs and house rent. A decree in the suit would mean fastening crippling financial liability on the homebuyers.In Sept last year, a Justice Kant-led bench ordered a CBI inquiry against a large number of builders and banks across India for colluding to misuse the tripartite subvention scheme and fleece the homebuyers even when the projects remained incomplete for decades.
Share your thoughts in the comments
Be respectful · TOI community guidelines
On Thursday, the bench found its sympathy for the homebuyers has virtually opened the floodgates of litigation and thousands of them suffering under the tyranny of builders and banks have rushed directly to SC. It said, “Our hands are full and we may not be able to handle fresh litigation.”In a similar case from Bengaluru involving over 4,000 homebuyers, it protected homebuyers against possible recovery proceedings from banks as the housing project remained incomplete for nearly a decade despite the petitioners paying 95% of the cost of the flat. After granting protection, the bench asked the petitioner’s counsel to move Karnataka HC for appropriate relief.






