Home / International News / An Illinois couple installed a fence after reporting trespassers near their bedroom window and a car theft, but their HOA challenged its placement; November 17 appeals judges upheld an order to move it

An Illinois couple installed a fence after reporting trespassers near their bedroom window and a car theft, but their HOA challenged its placement; November 17 appeals judges upheld an order to move it


An Illinois couple installed a fence after reporting trespassers near their bedroom window and a car theft, but their HOA challenged its placement; November 17 appeals judges upheld an order to move it
An Illinois court ordered the couple to relocate their fence within 120 days, rejecting HOA violations.

A fence that was meant to help a family feel safe in their own home has become the focus of a legal battle in an Illinois neighborhood, raising questions about the rights of homeowners and the power of homeowners associations. Vincent and Lekeisha Williams reported repeated trespassing, a stolen car and concerns for their family’s security, and erected a fence around their property. But their neighborhood association challenged the placement of the structure, saying it violated community restrictions. The dispute eventually made its way to an appeals court, which has now upheld an earlier order that the couple move the fence.

A couple built a fence for safety

The Appellate Court of Illinois said the dispute involved the Williams family, who owned a home in the Ashford Farms subdivision in St. Clair County. The couple had had a number of security incidents involving people on their property and appearing near their bedroom window. Lekeisha Williams testified at trial that the family had called police on several occasions about their trespassing concerns. To make matters worse, their vehicle was stolen from the yard. Vincent Williams also shared stories about their business, including the burglaries at the family pharmacy.Fearing for their safety, the couple opted to put a fence that would surround areas around their house that were vulnerable, including windows and an electrical box. They said the structure had helped to avoid further incidents. But the fence’s location soon led to a dispute with the Ashford Farms Homeowners Association.

HOA disputes placement of fence per community guidelines

The Illinois Appellate Court said restrictive covenants in the subdivision required residents to obtain written architectural approval before putting up fences or making certain changes to the outside of their homes. The rules also restricted fencing in certain areas of residential properties and gave the association’s architectural committee authority over the placement, height and materials of approved structures. The committee initially rejected the Williamses’ preferred placement, but later proposed a compromise to allow the fence to extend to about the middle of their house. But the couple put it further forward in the home. They were issued a compliance notice in March 2023 and given 30 days to rectify the violation, but did not remove the structure. The association then sued to enforce the neighborhood restrictions.

Court dismisses couple’s selective enforcement argument

In October 2024, the Williamses argued at the bench trial other properties in the subdivision had fences that apparently violated similar requirements. They also provided evidence of the trespass incidents and explained that the alternate location suggested by the association would not provide sufficient protection to the area adjacent to their bedroom window. However, the association’s property manager testified that another homeowner with a fence in a similar situation was also sued and told to take it down.In April 2025, the trial court found in favor of the association, ruling that the couple had installed the structure without the required approval. It ordered them to move the fence back to the previously approved location within 120 days but denied the association attorney fees.

Appeals court supports fence move order

The Williamses appealed, saying their fence met the subdivision’s restrictions and that the association was picking and choosing which rules to enforce. They also questioned whether the architectural committee had properly approved the installation by failing to respond within the 60-day period required.But the Appellate Court of Illinois, Fifth District, denied their appeal and affirmed the lower court’s judgment in its November 17, 2026 decision.The judges decided the couple needed to get architectural approval even if the fence did not go all the way to the street. The committee had given permission for the structure to be installed halfway along the house but not at the front of the property. The court also found that not enough evidence of selective enforcement. The other homeowner the couple named had already gone through similar legal action and was told to take down a fence that had been put up illegally.As for the 60-day approval argument, the appeals judges refused to consider it because the couple had not raised the issue in the original trial. The court noted that the association was denied the opportunity to respond to the new argument raised at the stage of appeals.The ruling, issued on November 17, therefore upholds the original order to relocate the fence and requires the Williamses to move the fence to the position approved by the association.Image Courtesy: Google Gemini



Source link

Tagged:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *